| What a binder does | Provides a film-forming polymer that holds pigment particles together and helps anchor the printed layer to the substrate. | Performs the same basic film-forming and pigment-binding role; PU chemistry can be selected to provide different combinations of flexibility, toughness, and adhesion. | The binder is the polymer component of the ink, not the pigment. Pigments provide color; the binder helps form the durable printed film. |
| How a waterborne dispersion works | Polymer particles are dispersed in water. As water leaves the print, the particles come closer together and form a continuous film under suitable drying conditions. | PU particles are likewise carried in water and form a film as the water evaporates; film formation depends on the specific dispersion and drying conditions. | Drying removes water, while heat may be needed to support film formation or any specified curing reaction. Follow the ink supplier’s technical instructions. |
| Common film characteristics | Can range from relatively soft and flexible to harder films. Acrylic systems are often chosen when color clarity, hardness, or weathering performance is important. | Often used where flexibility, abrasion resistance, or adhesion is desired, although actual performance varies with PU structure and formulation. | These are broad tendencies, not guarantees. Pigment loading, additives, substrate, film thickness, and cure all affect the finished print. |
| Potential applications | Water-based printing inks for suitable textiles, paper, and other compatible surfaces. | Water-based inks and coatings for applications that may require a flexible or tough film on a compatible surface. | Always check substrate compatibility. A binder suitable for fabric may not be suitable for paper, plastic, or another surface. |
| Flexibility and hand feel | Flexibility depends on the polymer grade and formulation; a harder acrylic film may feel less flexible than a softer one. | Many PU dispersions can provide flexible films, but softness and stretch performance depend on the particular chemistry and formulation. | For textiles, assess the printed fabric after the specified cure, including stretch, cracking, and hand feel. |
| Durability considerations | Can provide useful film strength and resistance properties when formulated and cured for the intended application. | Can be selected for demanding flexibility or wear requirements, subject to the formulation and correct processing. | Wash, rub, abrasion, and adhesion performance must be verified with tests appropriate to the end use. |
| Curing and crosslinking | Some formulations rely mainly on drying and film formation; others may use additional crosslinking chemistry to improve performance. | Some formulations also use crosslinkers or other curing aids; whether these are needed depends on the product and performance target. | Do not assume that all water-based binders cure identically. Use the stated time, temperature, and handling guidance for the specific ink. |
| Choosing between them | Consider when the required balance of film hardness, clarity, weathering, adhesion, and cost fits an acrylic-based system. | Consider when the required balance of flexibility, toughness, abrasion resistance, and adhesion fits a PU-based system. | Compare technical data and test prints on the actual substrate. Formulation and processing often matter as much as the polymer family. |